CWD Assumptions

Lots of news about chronic wasting disease arrived by email, answering machine and calculator-keyed analyses during May.

Then again, maybe it’s not news. Or maybe it’s old news. Or maybe I’m overreacting to information I requested. Take a look. You decide if these items sounds “newsy.”

— Preliminary results from a study starting in 2009 show that five of 18 macaque monkeys exposed to CWD contracted the always-fatal disease. Three got sick by eating CWD-infected materials, two from meat and one from brain matter. The other two got sick after their brains were injected with CWD-infected materials.

Results aren’t yet in on the study’s other 13 macaques. The research is led by Stefanie Czub at the Canadian Food Inspection Agency, and funded by the Alberta Prion Research Institute. Macaques are genetically closer to humans than squirrel monkeys, which previously were found susceptible to prions, the rogue protein that triggers CWD.

— Only 10 percent of deer shot in Wisconsin’s four most-diseased counties – Dane, Iowa, Sauk and Richland – were tested for CWD during 2016’s hunting seasons.

— Hunters in those counties registered 23,162 whitetails last fall, and provided test-samples from 2,350 to the Department of Natural Resources. Of those tested, 411, or 17.5 percent, carried CWD. The infection rates were: Dane, 7.3 percent (41 cases); Iowa, 25 percent (220 cases); Sauk, 20.4 percent (90 cases); and Richland, 12.8 percent (60 cases).

— If those numbers indicate the counties’ CWD prevalence, untested venison from about 3,537 diseased deer will be consumed unknowingly by hunters and their families this year.

When asked about such numbers, former Natural Resources Board chairman Dave Clausen of Amery said: “This is one of the most outrageous human susceptibility experiments in history.”

deer in field

Only 10 percent of deer shot or arrowed in Wisconsin’s four most CWD-infected counties were tested for the disease in 2016

— Since CWD was discovered in December 2013 in a 5-year-old buck shot inside fences at the Wilderness Whitetails deer farm in Marathon County, 24 more deer there have tested positive for CWD. Three were found in 2014, nine in autumn 2015 and 12 in autumn 2016.

The preserve currently holds 310 deer on 351 acres, and tested 242 for CWD from January 2014 through December 2016, according to Wisconsin’s Department of Agriculture, Trade and Consumer Protection. Starting in 2002, Wilderness Whitetails tested 373 deer before finding its first case 11 years later.

— Since CWD was discovered in December 2015 in a 3-year-old buck shot inside the fence of the Three Lakes Trophy Ranch in Oneida County, six more deer there tested positive, including five in autumn 2016. The preserve currently holds about 545 whitetails on 570 acres, and tested 30 the past two years, according to DATCP.

— Since CWD was discovered in September 2016 in an 18-month-old doe killed inside the fence of the Apple Creek Game Farm in Oconto County, seven more deer there tested positive last autumn. The preserve currently holds about 1,858 whitetails on 1,363 acres, and tested 466 in 2016, according to DATCP. Starting in 2009, Apple Creek tested 1,192 deer for CWD before finding its first CWD case last year.

— The Three Lakes and Apple Creek deer farms have a second barrier, a three-strand electrical fence, surrounding their enclosures, according to DATCP, which said Wilderness Whitetails does not have “enhanced fencing.”

governor scott walker on cwd

Is CWD being taken serious enough across the state of Wisconsin?

— After announcing initial CWD discoveries at individual deer farms, DATCP issues no further press releases when more deer test positive. “We expect to get additional positives. We don’t consider that news,” said Paul McGraw, state veterinarian.

McGraw also said he wasn’t surprised to see three straight years of increased CWD cases at Wilderness Whitetails and two straight years of increases at Three Lakes. “This is typical when you go in and cull more heavily,” he said.

— DATCP doesn’t expect to “depopulate” any of the three Northwoods facilities, which continue to sell “hunts” to paying clients. Instead, all deer killed at the farms must be tested.

The last time DATCP exterminated a captive herd was November 2015, when it killed 228 whitetails inside a 10-acre facility in Eau Claire County, and paid its owner, Richard Vojtik, $298,770 in compensation. Thirty-four of those deer carried CWD (15 percent), and two bucks with CWD escaped before the herd was destroyed. The two bucks roamed free five months before being shot and tested.

McGraw doesn’t think the three facilities pose a significant threat to Wisconsin’s free-ranging Northwoods deer, either by escaping or by interacting along the wire-mesh fencelines with wild deer. “We have CWD in Wisconsin, and there are lots of ways prions can move,” McGraw said, adding that CWD could be spread by feeds, plant materials, tainted soils or bones from infected carcasses.

Other CWD experts disagree. Bryan Richards, CWD project leader at the U.S. Geological Survey’s National Wildlife Heath Center in Madison, said the three game farms “constitute a real and significant threat to the integrity of northern Wisconsin’s deer herd.”

Richards said the facilities’ high numbers of CWD-positive deer pose an “ongoing risk of disease escaping into the wild.” In fact, Richards said those numbers are “reminiscent of the Hall Farm in Portage County where prevalence reached nearly 80 percent” in the 70-acre enclosure when DATCP killed its 76 deer in 2006. Sixty of those deer had CWD.

 

 

Meanwhile, the DNR says little about CWD. Its deputy secretary, Kurt Thiede, spent 30 seconds discussing CWD during his 18-minute address to the Wisconsin Conservation Congress at its statewide convention May 12 in Oshkosh.

Thiede said the agency remains committed to limiting CWD’s spread, but didn’t specify how. And he certainly didn’t mention those three infected deer farms or the abysmal 10 percent testing rate in Dane, Iowa, Sauk and Richland counties.

governor scott walker discusses cwd

Wisconsin Gov. Scott Walker addresses the Wisconsin Conservation Congress on May 12 in Oshkosh.

Soon after Thiede’s talk, Gov. Scott Walker used about two of his 22 minutes at the podium to share some “good news” regarding CWD. That is, if you got your deer tested in 2016, you received your results in less than 10 days. As recently as 2012 the DNR averaged 20 days to send results.

Folks, if that’s the only CWD information this administration shares willingly, it knows nothing about news – let alone CWD’s risk to Wisconsin’s deer herd.

Patrick Durkin

Patrick Durkin

President at Wisconsin Outdoor Communicators Association
Patrick Durkin is a lifelong bowhunter and full-time freelance outdoor writer/editor who lives in Waupaca, Wisconsin. He has covered hunting, fishing and outdoor issues since 1983. His work appears regularly in national hunting publications, and his weekly outdoors column has appeared regularly in over 20 Wisconsin newspapers since 1984.
Patrick Durkin

Comments

  1. Jonny Max says:

    Patrick, you always have a lot of complaints about the ways CWD is being handled (or not being handled). I don’t really understand your alternatives. You have a platform to educate us, Wisconsin hunters, but all you’ve done is complain about Walker, the DNR, and their lack of transparency when dealing with CWD.

    What can we do, as hunters, to attack this disease? Are you saying more hunters need to submit their deer for testing? Do we need to be eliminating more of the deer population in certain areas? What are things that we can focus on?

    Reply
  2. Terry Singeltary says:

    Subject: PRION 2017 CONFERENCE DECIPHERING NEURODEGENERATIVE DISORDERS VIDEO

    thought everyone would like/should watch this…kind regards, terry

    Subject: PRION 2017 CONFERENCE DECIPHERING NEURODEGENERATIVE DISORDERS VIDEO

    PRION 2017 CONFERENCE DECIPHERING NEURODEGENERATIVE DISORDERS

    PRION 2017 CONFERENCE VIDEO

    link to youtube.com

    link to prion2017.org

    Thursday, June 29, 2017

    PRION 2017 CONFERENCE DECIPHERING NEURODEGENERATIVE DISORDERS VIDEO

    link to prionprp.blogspot.com

    link to chronic-wasting-disease.blogspot.com

    Terry S. Singeltary Sr.

    Reply
  3. LeniesO says:

    I agree Johny. Pat the soapbox is getting tiresome and people are starting to tune out so to speak. I agree with all of your numbers and all of your concerns but instead of just talking about problems maybe start suggesting the solutions. If it’s just to bring awareness that CWD is still there and getting worse that’s fine… you’re doing great at that. How are going to fix it? Write about that.

    Reply
  4. Terry Singeltary says:

    i thought some of you here might want an update on the cwd tse prion disease.

    here goes, it’s not pretty, so don’t shoot the messenger, i am full of holes…terry

    SATURDAY, NOVEMBER 10, 2018

    Pennsylvania Thirty-Eight Deer Test Positive for Chronic Wasting Disease on Fulton and Bedford County Deer Farms

    link to chronic-wasting-disease.blogspot.com

    SATURDAY, NOVEMBER 10, 2018

    cwd, bse, scrapie, cjd, tse prion updated November 10 2018

    link to chronic-wasting-disease.blogspot.com

    THURSDAY, OCTOBER 25, 2018

    ***> Norway New additional requirements for imports of hay and straw for animal feed from countries outside the EEA due to CWD TSE Prion

    link to chronic-wasting-disease.blogspot.com

    THURSDAY, OCTOBER 04, 2018

    ***> Cervid to human prion transmission 5R01NS088604-04 Update

    link to chronic-wasting-disease.blogspot.com

    Reply

Speak Your Mind

*