Choosing a Broadhead: Mechanical vs. Fixed

Every bowhunter has had a range of experiences with broadheads – the good, the bad and the ugly.  They may blame a lost animal on their heads when the real cause is something completely different.  Or they may attribute their success to their heads when any head that would stay in one in piece could have cleanly killed the animal.  It doesn’t matter – sometimes physics takes the backseat.  This is an emotional subject.

I have never gotten into a heated argument in hunting camp about which bow is the best, but I have certainly been in a number of them when it comes to broadheads.

In this article, I hope to cut through the emotion (I have my own biases, of course) and get down to the physics of arrow flight and an understanding of the tradeoffs we are making.  I hope when you are done reading this you will view broadhead selection with a different, more open-minded attitude.

D07-3815 (Custom) (Custom).jpg

Mechanical heads open two different ways. They can either open from the front backwards, like this model, or from the back forward. Both have their followers and both are solid choices.

MECHANICAL HEADS

I consider myself conservative when it comes to equipment selection, a slow adopter, but I have never felt uncomfortable about mechanical heads.  Here is why I like them.

Accuracy is the most important goal of any shot – whether at a target or at game.  That has to be priority number one.  I have talked with many broadhead makers over the years and even those that didn’t make mechanical heads stated that any broadhead that stays more or less in one piece will kill a deer-sized animal if you hit it in the right place.

So, hitting them in the right place is obviously a big deal – dare I say, the biggest deal?  There are many fixed-blade heads that fly nearly as well as field points under a wide range of conditions, but back in 1995 when I made the switch to mechanicals, there weren’t any.  I fought to achieve good accuracy on shots past 25 yards with the fixed-blade heads of that day.  My biggest problems occurred with bows that were a bit quirky (some of those bows were impossible to tune) and when shooting in the wind.  Achieving accuracy with fast arrows was a huge challenge.  I spent many days each year tweaking and making tiny changes to improve my accuracy.

When I first began trying mechanical heads, taking them to the field to use on live game was a no-brainer.  My accuracy was so much more consistent; my confidence surged.  Knowing you will hit where you are aiming is huge.

More than a decade later, I am sure that I have shot well over 200 big game animals (I shoot does everywhere I hunt) with mechanical heads.  My recovery rate has been very high.  I can’t think of a single shot that I would take again with a different head.  I have never had reason to question the effectiveness of the mechanical heads I have used.  I’m sure there are situations where they are inferior to fixed-blade heads, but I have not encountered those situations personally.

3282 (Custom) (Custom).jpg

Small conservative mechanical heads with cutting diameters under 1 1/2 inches will penetrate as well as most fixed blade broadheads.

As a qualifier to the previous paragraph, it is worth noting that I shoot conservative heads with relatively small (1 1/4 inch) cutting diameters and short blades that open easily on impact.  These heads don’t affect penetration adversely (I’ve done the tests) and I have never seen them pole-vault (a phenomenon similar to skipping a rock, that supposedly occurs on angled hits).  I shoot heavy arrows so that might also contribute to the performance of these heads.

So much for personal experience, now let’s look at the physics.  Anytime you put a wing at the front of a projectile, you have the potential for steering.  That is exactly what you are doing when you attach a fixed-blade broadhead to your arrow.

You work hard to figure out how best to shoot a bow and you tinker with the tuning until you have great arrow flight.  Now, the last thing you want is an arrow that decides for itself which way it will go once it leaves the bow.  With a wing at the front, there is always that potential.  The larger the wing, the larger the potential problem.

I’m not saying a problem is guaranteed.  When you have a well-tuned bow, a perfectly straight arrow, with a nock, insert and broadhead all in alignment and when you hold good shooting form through the shot, you will shoot most fixed-blade heads accurately.  But if any of those elements breaks down, you will have a wind-planing issue.  And the faster it flies, the more it will wind-plane.

If you remove the wing from the front of the arrow, or reduce the size of the wing, you eliminate or reduce the possibility for a problem.  That is Aerodynamics 101.

The goal then becomes a combination of two tasks.  First, make the wing as small as possible.  Second, get the bow, arrow and your shooting form as good as possible.  The smallest wing is no wing, and that is the only reason to shoot mechanical broadheads.

D07-4038 (Custom) (Custom).jpg

Your choice in broadheads will end up being as much an emotional decision as a scientific one.

Selecting the best size: I want a small mechanical head that opens to roughly 1 1/4 to 1 1/2 inches.  I can understand why you might want a bigger style and I have spoken with many die-hard super-serious bowhunters who use mechanicals that open to two-inches, or more.

My arrows possess enough energy to shoot a mechanical that opens up to six inches, like a pair of steak knives.  That would be great on soft-tissue hits, but when I do have a slight bauble and hit the animal in the shoulder, I still need penetration.  You get better penetration with smaller heads.  I want to be able to kill a deer that I accidentally shoot in the shoulder.  With a smaller head, I increase the odds of a clean kill.

How it opens matters: When a mechanical head opens from the back forward, it acts more like a fixed-blade head on impact.  Less of the arrow’s energy is needed to open the blades and more of it is available to penetrate the animal.  If the blades open from the front back (the way most of them do) the shorter blades used in the smaller designs that I favor will not rob as much energy.

Mechanical heads are definitely a good choice for those who want the most accurate possible head, but they aren’t as durable as fixed-blade heads.  Because the blades of a mechanical head are unsupported, it is easier for them to break off on a bone hit.

FIXED-BLADE BROADHEADS

We need to go back to the analogy of the wing on the front of the arrow.  If we make the wing smaller, it has less potential to steer the arrow.  That is why I like the new category of fixed-blade heads that have dominated the market during the past three years.  They have short, compact blades with high blade angles.  Like mechanical broadheads with short blades, they create more of a chopping affect than a slicing affect.

Most of us can live with a chopping affect as long as the head hits where we aim.  That is the strength of these heads; by reducing the amount of blade surface area, they fly better under a wider range of conditions and at higher arrow speeds.

Here are a few examples of this style of broadhead.  There are many on the market now and I will probably miss a few, but you will at least get the idea.  Look at the New Archery Products Nitron, Muzzy MX-3, Slick Trick, American Broadheads Sonic, Wac’ Em, Aftershock Maniac, Steel Force Sabertooth HP, Tight Point Shuttle T-Lock, Rocky Mountain Blitz, Grim Reaper Hades, G5 Striker, Rocket Bunker Buster, Wasp Boss and Innerloc Stainless Extreme.  Cut-to-the-point versions include the Magnus Stinger and the NAP Hell Razor.

These are just some of the newest heads on the market.  The list is in no way comprehensive.  There are literally dozens of different fixed blade broadhead models.  Not only can you choose between several different styles of replaceable blade heads, but you can also choose between several different styles of cut-on-impact one-piece heads.  The choices can seem bewildering, but I will try to bring a little order to the tradeoffs so you can see through the fog of options.

hellrazor.jpg

Cut to the point heads such as this NAP HellRazor are the hands down penetration leaders.  However, every broadhead choice comes with some tradeoffs.

Style: As mentioned, you can choose between one-piece cut-on-impact heads or replaceable-blade heads.  Both styles have their advantages.  Recently, the cut-on-impact heads have really improved to the point where they will fly well even from fast compound bows.  There is no reason not to try them.  It is the perfect choice if your number one goal is penetration.  A two-bladed cut-on-impact head will penetrate better than anything else on the market, bar none.

Replaceable-blade heads are obviously easier for the majority of bowhunters to use because you don’t need to sharpen the blades.  When you shoot them, simply replace the blades with new ones.  Most replaceable blade heads have three blades, some have four blades and a very few have two blades.

Cutting diameter: Cutting diameter creates another tradeoff.  A large cutting diameter means more surface to potentially steer the arrow offline if you are using a fixed-blade head.  However, on impact, especially with soft tissue, having a large cutting diameter increases the chances for quick kill.  Each person must make this tradeoff for themselves, but if I were going to shoot fixed-blade heads again, I would shoot those with cutting diameters in the 1 1/4 inch size – or even slightly smaller.

Number of blades: The more blades the head has, the less it will penetrate.  This is because every blade encounters resistance when it cuts into the animal.  The more blades, the more resistance.  Beyond a certain point, you gain very little tissue damage by increasing the number of blades.  I don’t see much value in shooting heads with more than three blades.  The only exception being cut-on-impact heads with two primary blades and two smaller bleeder blades.  In this case, a four-bladed head makes sense.

If you know you are going to make a perfect hit, the broadhead you choose isn’t important.  It has only to be sharp.  However, making a perfect hit is where the challenge lies.  First you need to figure out how you will make it and then you have to reduce the downside if you don’t.  Those are the two big issues when selecting broadheads.

Strive to choose a broadhead that lets you zip your hunting arrows just as accurately as your field point tipped practice arrows.  While accuracy is priority number one, it is never guaranteed.  If you choose carefully, you will also end up with a head that offers all the penetration you need to make good on a shoulder hit.

InnerlocStainlessExtreme (Custom) (Custom).jpg

Compact broadheads with limited blade surface will produce the best accuracy among the fixed blade style because they minimize blade surface that can steer the arrow off line.

Comments

  1. Travis fox says:

    i am 21 i have hunted since i could walk. I am not trying to act like a know it all but when it comes to mechanical vs fixed blade, i believe hands down rage mechanical 2 blade is the best you can buy. Rage 2 blades leave the most devistarting entrey and exit holes. lets face it life and death is all about gods will and physics and when it comes to physics of killing a whitetail deer range dominates.

    Reply
  2. Andy Estes says:

    I have read a lot about the Rage, and all of it isn't good. I talked to a guy who hit a doe in the shoulder and the arrow actually came out the same hole it went in. He got the deer, but wasn't happy at all with the broadhead. He now shoots G5 Montec. I shoot Grim Reaper mechanical.

    Reply
  3. Derrick Tomes says:

    Rage is a good broadhead but rocket broadheads meatseeker is just as good if not better.

    Reply
  4. justin mast says:

    rage broudheads never would fly straight enough 4 me i personally like g5 montec the best. they fly straight and group like a field point

    Reply
  5. PK Snowden(Buzzy) says:

    I recently bought Rage boudheads for my sons bow at the advise of the salesman/bow expert and so far the only thing I don't like about them is when in the woods on the ground with an arrow on the nock any movment made has the posibility of opening the tip and if not noticed and making a shot I would think this would throw off the accuracy of the arrow in flight to the point of missing all together.If anyone has any knowledge of this please let me know,Thanks,great article,PK"Buzzy"Snowden

    Reply
  6. Many problems with mech heads….ultimate steel is my chice fixed blade, fly same as practice tip and complete pass through even on shoulder shots.

    Reply
  7. Justin Perkins says:

    I have shot both, mechanicals and fixed blades and i like both just the same as long as you get a good quality head it will get the job done. I killed 2 deer with the rage and 2 with the G5 striker in the past 2 years the rage leaves more blood but the striker is a bone buster, just depends on your preference. hope this helps.

    Reply
  8. I would be uneasy with the mechanicals,because of the rubber bands used,i shoot ultimate steel 100gr fixed /3blades & shot a deer this season at 30yds thru both shoulder blades& out the other side.

    Reply
  9. casey fenlon says:

    i am 14 and just got a bow last year so this is my first year bow hunting and i realy dont no wat broadhead to get. which one should i get

    Reply
  10. Jason Terry says:

    after hunting with mechanicals (thunderhead spitfire 100s) for several years i'm going back to a fixed blade (muzzy 100s). biggest reason? i've now had two spitfires that failed to open on impact because of contact with bone. both were very legitimate shots in good location, but i just can't continue to hunt with a broad head that may not open and keep a good conscience. when they work, boy do they work! but when they don't its one of the worst feelings a hunter can ever experience. i just respect the animal too much.

    Reply
  11. For the gentleman that said he had a problem with the Rage broadhead not staying closed until impact. The blades utilize a slide cam system. When you set the blades in the closed position by sliding them uo and folding the bootom of the blades in, you have to make sure the notches at the bottom inside edge of the blades snap into the o-ring around the bottom shaft of the broadhead. If the are snapped in correctly, they shouldnt open until impact. If they do, it is a defect in the blades. I havnt had a problem with them. Hope this helps.

    Reply
  12. im switching back to fixed broadheads prob the montecg5 i had the same problem with the rages opening when grabing my bow and hitting a limb or just walking into the woods i recently shot a buck with the tru fire switchback and had almost no blood even though making a lung shot and hearing him crash 70 yards I also just lost a big buck with the switchback after a liver shot and only finding blood at initial contact nothing but a few drips 10 yards later the first buck still had the broadhead in him when gutting him and im sure the same with the one that got away

    Reply
  13. I have seen some pretty impressive wound channels on deer with mechanicals , the Rocket steel three blade mechanical is a dependable one with a 1&1/4 cut. The last few years I have been experimenting with several fixed blades , the magnus 2 blade (old style ) seems to kill as good as any of the new high dollar heads do( go figure. I think accuracy should be your #1 concern and good arrow flight second(Well tuned Bow & good shooting form) The mechanical broad head was not invented to kill better but to cover ones inability to shoot accurately and maintain a well tuned bow. It dosent realy matter if you have the best broad head on the planet with out accuracy you want hit vitals and the animal leaves to die miserable and waste. With out good arow flight penetration will be inconsistant depending on the arrow deftion .

    Reply
  14. If you want a mechanical that wont open accidently and flies like a field point, E.P.E.K., I have shot Muzzy, Spitfire, and Rage. Rage was the worst. E.P.E.K.

    Reply
  15. I shoot slick trick 4 blades and they work good for me, In idaho I have to use a fixed blade head, no choice.

    Reply
  16. What about Shwacker mechanical broadheads? Has anyone shot these

    Reply
  17. Chuck Fowler says:

    I have used both Rage and Montec. The rage are ok if you are ok with them opening up. I known people say do this and that but they still open prematurely. The montecs fly great and do awesome on deer. Go to youtube and search for broadhead tests. You will see a variety of videos. Mixed results on rage but no bad tests for montec.

    Reply
  18. While the author seemed incredibly biased towards mechanicals, there is a reason that some states don't allow mechanical broadheads. More moving parts=higher chance of something malfunctioning. Mech broadheads were invented for archers that are either inexperienced, unwilling, or just plain too lazy to take the time to figure out tuning their bows. I shoot a 175 grain 2 blade fixed head (Simmons Tigershark) out of my Mathews Z7, flies like my field points. Do your research ladies and gentleman! If you can bend a broadheads blades with a gloved hand, think about what a shoulder bone, or turkey will do to it. Plus sharpening broadheads is a lot of fun imo.

    Reply
  19. Bill Lau says:

    I think it is a great idea to shoot mechanicals because that way you can blame them when making a poor shot.

    Reply
  20. I changed to Rage 3 blade. I was using a mechanical I bought at walmart. I lost a nice doe because the blades didnt open the reason I can say this is the arrow hit in the ribs and only had about 5 IN. of penatration no blood trail at all .I found my arrow about 30 yards from where I hit her, very little blood on the arrow no blood around the arrow except 1 drop when these tips work its awsome but when thy dont its not good at all.I hope I have a lot better luck with rage

    Reply
  21. What about the Afflicter? I heard the Pigman is using it and thinks it is hands down the best broadhead ever made!

    Reply

Speak Your Mind

*